Alchemy Hill Advisory

Comparisons

Repositioning or rebranding: which one do you actually need?

Identity projects fail when they change the look without changing the claim. Here is the distinction, and a six-question test to run before you brief a designer.

The distinction

A rebrand changes how you look. A reposition changes what you are. If the growth problem would remain unexplained after a visual refresh, you have a positioning problem.

You need a rebrand

The claim is right and the expression has aged out of it.

  • Everyone internally describes the business the same way, and that description is still true
  • Won customers repeat your claim back to you unprompted
  • You are winning against the competitors you want to be compared with
  • The identity was drafted for a much smaller version of the company

You need a reposition

The claim itself no longer matches the business, or never resolved.

  • Five people write five different one-sentence claims
  • The pipeline fills with bargain hunters and mismatches
  • Pricing power is eroding and discounting is creeping
  • You have already done a refresh and nothing commercial moved

Steal this

The Refresh-or-Reposition test

Answer yes or no as a leadership team, separately, without conferring. Then compare.

  1. Can five people across the business write the same one-sentence claim, independently?
  2. Do won customers describe you in roughly that sentence, unprompted?
  3. Are you winning against the competitors you actually want to be compared with?
  4. Does the pipeline fill with right-fit buyers rather than bargain hunters?
  5. Has the claim survived the last two years of product and market change intact?
  6. If the visual identity stayed exactly as it is, would the growth problem remain unexplained?

Reading it: Four or more yes: a refresh will do. Four or more no: you need a reposition. A split result is the most useful outcome of all. It means the claim is contested at the top, and that is the finding.

Most businesses that book a rebrand need a reposition, and find out expensively. The order matters: decide the claim, then dress it.

Read the moment →